Squishmallows vs. FruitBumz: Comparing Plush Lines for Collectors

If you're a plush collector, you've likely encountered both Squishmallows and Bumz. While Squishmallows dominate the market with their marshmallow-like softness and vast character roster, Bumz—especially FruitBumz—offer a quirky, fruit-themed alternative that's hard to resist. But which line is right for you? In this comparison, we'll break down the key differences in size, texture, design, and collectibility to help you decide.

Both brands are known for their ultra-soft fabrics and huggable shapes, but they cater to slightly different tastes. Squishmallows come in hundreds of characters, from fantasy creatures to licensed favorites like Hello Kitty. Bumz, on the other hand, focus on food and object themes with a signature beanbag-like feel. Let's dive into the details.

Size and Shape Differences

Squishmallows are available in a wide range of sizes, from 3.5-inch clips to 24-inch jumbo plush. Their classic round, pillowy shape makes them perfect for cuddling or displaying on a bed. In contrast, FruitBumz are typically smaller—around 4.5 inches—and have a flatter, beanbag-like silhouette that sits upright. This makes Bumz ideal for desk or shelf displays where space is limited.

If you prefer a plush you can hug, a 12-inch Squishmallow like the 12-Inch Bertina the Pink Ombré Pancakes offers a substantial, squishy feel. For a compact collectible that's easy to carry or arrange in groups, FruitBumz are the better choice. Their uniform size also makes them satisfying to line up by theme.

• Tip: Mix larger Squishmallows with smaller Bumz for visual variety on a shelf.

Texture and Fill Comparison

Squishmallows are filled with polyester fiber and a proprietary marshmallow-like stuffing that gives them a soft, slow-rising squish. The outer fabric is a velvety spandex blend that feels smooth to the touch. Bumz use a different fill—often a mix of beads and fiber—resulting in a weighted, beanbag feel that holds its shape well. The fabric is also soft but slightly more textured.

For cuddling, Squishmallows win with their plush, huggable feel. The 8-Inch Caspian the Lavender Skunk Holding Cake Slice is a great example of the soft, detailed plush you can snuggle. For fidgeting or desk play, the weighted feel of FruitBumz is satisfying. Collectors who enjoy both textures often keep Squishmallows on their bed and Bumz on their desk.

• Tip: If you have sensory preferences, try a Squishmallow for softness and a Bumz for a grounding weight.

Theme and Design Variety

Squishmallows boast an enormous range of themes—animals, fantasy, food, holidays, and licensed characters like Hello Kitty. The designs are often whimsical with embroidered faces and unique details. For instance, the 12-Inch Select Series Denny the St. Paddy's Day Troll features a festive hat and beard. Bumz, by contrast, focus on food and everyday objects, with FruitBumz being a sub-line of fruit-shaped characters. Their designs are simpler, with printed faces and a more minimalist aesthetic.

If you love variety and storytelling, Squishmallows offer endless options to build a themed collection. If you're drawn to kawaii fruit designs and a uniform look, FruitBumz are charming and easy to complete. Some collectors enjoy both: a shelf of Squishmallows for diversity and a row of FruitBumz for a tidy, colorful accent.

• Tip: Check for limited-edition Squishmallows like the 12-Inch Lana the Rainbow Lamb Sleepamallows for rare finds.

Price and Collectibility

Squishmallows vary widely in price depending on size and rarity, with standard 8-inch plush costing around $10–$15 and special editions fetching higher prices. Bumz are generally more affordable, with 4.5-inch FruitBumz often priced under $10. This makes Bumz an attractive entry point for new collectors or those on a budget.

However, Squishmallows have a larger secondary market, with rare characters appreciating in value. Bumz are collectible but typically retain a lower resale value. For investment-minded collectors, Squishmallows offer more potential. For casual fun, FruitBumz are a low-cost way to enjoy a themed set.

Both Squishmallows and FruitBumz have their strengths. Squishmallows are unbeatable for cuddling, variety, and investment potential, while FruitBumz excel as affordable, space-saving desk companions. Many collectors happily own both—using Squishmallows for bedtime and Bumz for display. Whichever you choose, you're adding soft, joyful plush to your life.