Top 10 Rarest Squishmallows to Add to Your Collection in 2025

For collectors and enthusiasts, the hunt for rare Squishmallows is more than a hobby—it's a passion. In 2025, the market for limited edition Squishmallows continues to grow, with some plush reaching impressive resale values. Whether you're building your Squishmallows collection or looking for valuable Squishmallows to invest in, knowing which ones are truly scarce is key. In this guide, we count down the top 10 rarest Squishmallows to add to your collection in 2025, with expert tips on how to spot and secure these coveted treasures.

What Makes a Squishmallow Rare?

Before diving into the list, it's important to understand the factors that make a Squishmallow rare. Rarity often stems from limited production runs, exclusive releases (like store-specific or event-only drops), or discontinued designs. Squishmallows that are retired early or tied to a specific holiday or collaboration tend to become highly sought after. The condition, size, and original packaging also play a role in their collectibility. For instance, a plush that came in a mystery pack can be harder to find, making it more valuable.

The Top 10 Rarest Squishmallows of 2025

Here are our picks for the rarest Squishmallows you should keep an eye on this year. Note that availability and prices can fluctuate, so act fast when you spot one!

1. 12-Inch Jordon the Purple Ghost Holding Jack O'Lantern

Halloween-themed Squishmallows are always popular, but Jordon the Purple Ghost is a standout. This 12-inch plush, released exclusively for the spooky season, features a cute ghost design with a pumpkin accessory. Its limited holiday run makes it one of the rarest Squishmallows on the market, often selling out within hours of restock. If you see it, grab it—it's a near-guaranteed addition to any serious collection.

2. 12-Inch Monica the Purple Axolotl Holding Present

Axolotls are fan favorites, and Monica is no exception. This version, holding a present, was a limited gift-themed release that quickly became a collector's dream. Its vibrant purple color and rare accessory make it a must-have for those looking for valuable Squishmallows. Expect to pay a premium on secondary markets.

3. Hello Kitty and Friends 8-Inch My Melody Squishmallows

The collaboration between Squishmallows and Sanrio's Hello Kitty series created massive demand. The 8-inch My Melody plush, in particular, is a unicorn for collectors. Its crossover appeal and limited production numbers push it high on the rarity scale. Finding one in mint condition is a challenge, making it a top target for Squishmallows investing.

4. 8-Inch Mystery Plush 4 Pack

Mystery packs are inherently unpredictable, and this 4-pack release from 2024 is now incredibly hard to find. Each pack contained random Squishmallows, with some exclusive designs that never saw individual release. Because you never know what you'll get, the thrill—and the rarity—is amplified. Collectors often buy multiple packs hoping for a jackpot.

5. 20-Inch Anjali the Purple Elephant

Large Squishmallows (20 inches and above) are less common, and Anjali the Purple Elephant is a prime example. This jumbo plush was part of a limited run, and its size makes it both a statement piece and a challenge to store. For serious collectors, having a 20-inch Anjali is a status symbol. Its rarity is tied to its limited production and high demand among those who love oversized plush.

6. Five Nights at Freddy’s Endo-01 (Classic Foxy and Withered Foxy)

The collaboration with Five Nights at Freddy's brought a wave of new fans to Squishmallows. The Endo-01 figure, which includes Classic Foxy and Withered Foxy, is a rare find because it blends two characters in one set. This crossover was produced in limited quantities, and the horror-themed design appeals to both gamers and plush collectors.

7. AEW Swerve Strickland (Vault Edition)

Wrestling-themed Squishmallows are a niche but passionate subcategory. The AEW Swerve Strickland Vault Edition is a rare gem, released in a small run for die-hard fans. Its detailed design and limited availability make it a valuable addition for those who collect both Squishmallows and wrestling memorabilia.

8. 8-Inch Select Series Lancelot the Chocolate Bunny

Select Series Squishmallows are specifically designed for collectors, with premium materials and unique colorways. Lancelot the Chocolate Bunny is a deliciously rare example, with a rich brown hue that stands out. Its Select Series status means it was never widely available, so finding one in good condition is a win.

9. Halo Douglas-042 (Halo Wars 2) Spartan Collection 6-Inch Articulated Figure

This isn't your typical plush—it's an articulated figure from the Halo franchise. The Douglas-042 Spartan is part of a limited collaboration, and its poseability and detailed armor make it a collector's item for gamers. Its rarity comes from being a niche crossover, produced in small numbers.

10. Candy Charlize

Rounding out our list is Candy Charlize, a sweet-themed Squishmallow that was part of a limited candy-inspired series. Its vibrant design and short production run make it a hidden gem. Many collectors overlook it, but those in the know consider it a must-have for a complete collection.

Tips for Finding Rare Squishmallows

Hunting for rare Squishmallows requires strategy. Here are some proven tips:

• Follow restock alerts: Sign up for notifications on Squishmallows' official site and follow retailer social media accounts for restock announcements.
• Check local stores: Sometimes rare finds pop up in unexpected places like independent toy shops or department stores.
• Join collector communities: Online forums and Facebook groups dedicated to Squishmallows are goldmines for trade and sale alerts.
• Be patient and persistent: Rarity means competition, so set aside time each week to browse new listings.

Are Rare Squishmallows a Good Investment?

For many collectors, Squishmallows investing is a serious side hustle. While not all plush appreciate in value, rare and limited edition ones often sell for 2-5 times their original price on secondary markets. However, treat it as a hobby first—buy what you love, and the value may follow. Keep your plush in pristine condition, with tags intact, to maximize resale potential.

Conclusion: Build Your Dream Collection

Whether you're after the hauntingly cute Jordon or the sweet Candy Charlize, the thrill of the hunt is part of the fun. In 2025, the world of rare Squishmallows is more exciting than ever. Start with one or two of our top picks, and you'll soon have a collection that turns heads—and holds its value. Don't wait too long, because these plush vanish fast!

Call to Action

Ready to add a rare gem to your collection? Check out our 12-Inch Jordon the Purple Ghost Holding Jack O'Lantern while supplies last—it's the perfect spooky addition for any enthusiast!